123 William Street Loan Heads to Special Servicing
A $140 million CMBS loan on 123 William Street in Manhattan's Financial District moved to special servicing after the office building's occupancy fell.
By Erick Tarray · · 2 min read
Downtown Manhattan's office rebound has skipped at least one address. A $140 million commercial mortgage-backed securities loan on 123 William Street has moved to special servicing, the team that handles troubled CMBS loans, Commercial Observer reported, citing Morningstar Credit [2].
The 27-story Financial District tower belongs to American Strategic Investment Co., which said in its latest 10-Q that the loan's looming maturity raises substantial doubt about its ability to keep going [1][2].
How we got here
- Occupancy was 92% when the loan was underwritten and 72% by June 2026, per Morningstar figures reported by Commercial Observer [2].
- Morningstar's David Putro said occupancy slid from 91% to 72% over the past two and a half years [2].
- The loan has a fixed rate of 4.74% and is due in March 2027 [1].
- Planned Parenthood, the largest tenant, fills about 12% of the office space [2].
But the owner's trouble runs wider than one tower. American Strategic posted a $6.7 million third-quarter net loss, and another of its Manhattan office properties is going through a consensual foreclosure [1]. Its plans include trying to refinance or sell 123 William Street, and its advisor has offered to lend money if needed [1].
What it means for you
Older office loans were written at rates that no longer exist. By our math, the 4.74% coupon costs about $6.6 million a year in interest on $140 million [1]. Each extra percentage point on a refinance would add about $1.4 million a year, by our math, before any lost rent from a building that is 72% leased [2].
Zoom out
Putro called the exodus of tenants "a slow bleed" [2]. Across older Manhattan offices, loans maturing in 2027 face the same squeeze of lower occupancy and costlier debt.
This is market commentary, not investment advice.
Sources
- [1]SEC EDGAR, American Strategic Investment Co. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, Nov 13, 2026.
- [2]Commercial Observer, CMBS Loan Backing 123 William Street Enters Special Servicing Amid Owners' Bankruptcy Risks, Nov 19, 2026.






