Title Groups Urge Court to Keep FinCEN Rule Dead
Two title industry associations have asked a federal appeals court to preserve a March ruling that struck down FinCEN's nationwide reporting rule for all-cash home purchases by entities and trusts.
By Raymond de Clairmont · · 2 min read
Buy a house with cash through an LLC, and for less than three weeks this spring, a title company had to tell the federal government who you really are [1]. Now the fight over whether that requirement comes back has moved to a federal appeals court.
Two trade groups, the American Land Title Association (ALTA) and its Texas counterpart, TLTA, filed friend of the court briefs in late October asking the Fifth Circuit to keep the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) rule off the books, HousingWire reported [1]. ALTA says FinCEN's $559.4 million estimate of the cost to comply understated the real burden on title firms [1].
How we got here
- Earlier FinCEN geographic targeting orders, in place since 2016, applied just to deals above $300,000 in high-risk cities such as Manhattan and Miami [2].
- The 2024 rule went national, dropped the price floor and was expected to capture roughly 800,000 transactions each year [2].
- U.S. District Judge Jeremy Kernodle vacated it in March, and the government appealed in early May, according to HousingWire [1].
- By FinCEN's own figures, the rule covered 800,000 to 850,000 transfers a year with compliance costing as much as $690 million, the judge noted [3].
But the courts are split. A federal judge in Jacksonville, Fla., upheld the rule in a separate suit brought by Fidelity National Financial, which has appealed to the Eleventh Circuit [3]. Treasury officials have cited estimates that $2.3 billion in illicit money moved through U.S. housing from 2015 to 2020 [2].
What it means for you
If you buy rentals with cash through an LLC or trust, nothing is due today, and FinCEN has said it will not demand retroactive reports for deals closed during the litigation [1]. Spread across 800,000 transfers, ALTA's disputed $559.4 million cost figure works out to about $700 per deal by our math, a cost that could show up in closing fees if the rule returns.
Zoom out
Cash is a big part of the market: about 28% of buyers paid all cash last year and roughly 22% of purchases involved entities such as LLCs, The Real Deal reported, citing the National Association of Realtors [2].
This is market commentary, not investment advice.
Sources
- [1]HousingWire, Will the Fifth Circuit keep FinCEN anti-money laundering rule off the books?, Nov 13, 2026.
- [2]The Real Deal, Disclosure rules around all-cash buyers struck down, Mar 24, 2026.
- [3]HousingWire, FNF appeals ruling upholding FinCEN AML rule, Apr 21, 2026.





